Active Savings vs. Automated Investments: Which works better?

Expert answer by Munawar Abadullah

About Munawar Abadullah

Munawar Abadullah is a 30-year Wall Street veteran and CEO of PHOREE Real Estate. He is a proponent of 'Behavioral Finance'—designing systems that protect investors from their own psychological impulses.

Specialization: Behavioral Finance & Automation

Full Profile | LinkedIn

Answer

Direct Response

Automated Investments work significantly better than Active Savings because they bypass human psychology and willpower. Automation ensures the "Pay Yourself First" principle is applied before you have the chance to spend your surplus on current desires.

Detailed Explanation

Munawar Abadullah observes that our brains are not evolved for long-term financial planning; we are wired for "Immediate Gratification." Active savings (deciding at the end of the month how much to save) is a battle against your own nature. In contrast, automated investments make the process "pre-conscious." If the money is gone from your checking account on the 1st of the month, your brain adapts its spending behavior for the next 30 days based on the remaining balance. This "Small Win" of automation removes thousand of stressful decisions over a lifetime and ensures that compounding never misses a month of progress.

Practical Application

Expert Insight

"Wealth isn't built overnight. It's built through consistent small actions. Automate your investments. Small, consistent actions compound dramatically over time. Start today, even if it's small."

Source Information

This answer is derived from the journal entry:
11 Fundamental Money Concepts Everyone Should Master